When the upstairs bedrooms stay hot even with the air conditioning running, replacing the existing AC with a similar unit may leave the underlying problem unresolved.
A homeowner in State College, PA, contacted MGM Mechanical about replacing an AC system that was struggling to cool their home. The existing setup paired a 1.5 ton air conditioner with a furnace that was more than 20 years old. Upstairs, the homeowner relied on window air conditioners to help keep the bedrooms comfortable.
After evaluating the home and discussing the homeowner’s preferences, MGM Mechanical installed two systems: a Bryant heat pump and coil paired with a Trane oil furnace for the first floor, and a Mitsubishi ducted system with new attic ductwork for the second floor.
The project addressed equipment capacity, aging heating equipment, and the need to deliver conditioned air directly to the upstairs rooms.
The Challenge Was Bigger Than an Aging Air Conditioner
During the initial visit, MGM Mechanical found that the existing 1.5 ton AC system was undersized even for the first floor. Asking that equipment to cool both floors left the upstairs bedrooms particularly difficult to keep comfortable.
MGM’s assessment put the home’s needs at approximately 4 to 5 tons of system capacity. The existing furnace also needed consideration. Pairing new cooling equipment with a furnace more than two decades old would leave a major part of the home’s comfort system dependent on aging equipment.
The homeowner originally requested a new air conditioner. The site evaluation showed why the replacement plan needed to consider the entire home.
A Separate System for Each Floor
Following additional discussion and a second site visit, MGM Mechanical and the homeowner agreed on a design that served each floor separately.
| Area | Equipment installed | Installation approach |
|---|---|---|
| First floor | 2.5 ton Bryant heat pump and coil paired with a Trane oil furnace | Heat pump cooling and heating with oil furnace heat available |
| Second floor | 2 ton Mitsubishi ducted system | Dedicated upstairs system with new ductwork in the attic |
This arrangement gave the second floor its own equipment and air distribution instead of continuing to depend on a system serving the home from downstairs.
For homeowners considering heating and cooling system replacement, this project illustrates why equipment selection and ductwork planning need to happen together.
Bryant Heat Pump With a Trane Oil Furnace Downstairs
For the first floor, MGM Mechanical installed a 2.5 ton Bryant heat pump and coil paired with a Trane oil furnace.
This combination provides two heating sources. The heat pump uses electricity, while the furnace provides oil heat when needed. The heat pump also supplies air conditioning during warmer weather.
For this project, the heating approach called for using the heat pump in milder weather and switching to oil heat below approximately 30°F.
That temperature is specific to this installation, rather than a rule for every home. The appropriate changeover point depends on equipment performance, the home’s heating needs, energy prices, and control settings.
For a homeowner replacing an older oil furnace and AC system, this type of setup offers a way to add heat pump heating while keeping oil heat available.
Upstairs Comfort Without Wall Mounted Units
The initial proposal included a separate upstairs mini split system. However, the homeowner did not want visible indoor units mounted on the bedroom walls.
MGM Mechanical adjusted the design to fit that preference.
The final installation included a 2 ton Mitsubishi ducted unit serving the second floor, with a new duct package installed in the attic. This provided a dedicated way to distribute conditioned air upstairs without the wall mounted heads the homeowner wanted to avoid.
Appearance matters when choosing a comfort system. Homeowners who prefer conventional vents should discuss ducted options during the planning process, along with the space and access needed for the equipment and ductwork.
Why a Larger AC Unit Is Not the Whole Answer
This State College project required more capacity, but the solution also changed how the home’s equipment served each floor.
Simply increasing equipment size does not explain how air will reach an upstairs bedroom or whether the existing ducts can handle the required airflow. A replacement plan needs to account for both the home’s heating and cooling needs and the distribution system.
In this home, MGM Mechanical addressed those concerns by giving the second floor a dedicated ducted system and replacing the aging downstairs equipment.
Other homes may call for a different approach. A properly designed single system can serve a two story home, and zoning may be an option where the equipment, controls, and ductwork support it. The right choice depends on the building and the problems the homeowner wants to solve.
What Other Homeowners Can Learn From This Project
If your home has hot upstairs bedrooms, window units supplementing central AC, or an aging furnace, bring those details into the replacement conversation early.
Useful questions to discuss during an evaluation include:
- Does the existing equipment have enough capacity for the spaces it serves?
- Can the ductwork deliver the airflow each floor needs?
- Would a separate upstairs system or a properly designed zoning solution make sense?
- Should the furnace be replaced along with the air conditioner?
- Are ducted options available if you do not want wall mounted indoor units?
- How would a heat pump work with an oil furnace in your home?
For this homeowner, the final installation combined a first floor heat pump and oil furnace with a separate Mitsubishi ducted system upstairs. The design addressed the undersized AC, replaced aging heating equipment, and respected the homeowner’s preference for an installation without wall mounted heads.
Planning an HVAC Replacement in State College PA
If your air conditioner struggles to cool the second floor, or you are weighing replacement options for an older furnace, MGM Mechanical can help evaluate the equipment and layout together.
This State College project shows how a replacement plan can account for different needs on each floor and the homeowner’s preferences for how the system looks inside the home.
Contact MGM Mechanical to discuss your heating and cooling project, or call 717-543-3034.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need two HVAC systems for a two story home?
Not necessarily. A properly designed single system can work in a two story home. Separate systems or zoning may be worth considering when the floors have different comfort needs or the existing air distribution is inadequate. In this project, MGM Mechanical installed a dedicated system for each floor.
Can I install a heat pump and still use oil heat?
Yes. A heat pump can be paired with a compatible oil furnace and appropriate controls. This project used a Bryant heat pump and coil with a Trane oil furnace for the first floor.
Can I cool upstairs bedrooms without wall mounted mini split units?
Yes, when the home has suitable space for a ducted installation. For this State College home, MGM Mechanical installed a Mitsubishi ducted unit with new attic ductwork to serve the upstairs rooms.
Should I replace an old furnace when replacing my air conditioner?
It depends on the furnace’s condition, age, compatibility, and the broader replacement plan. In this case, the homeowner chose to replace the furnace rather than pair new cooling equipment with a unit more than 20 years old.
Should every heat pump switch to furnace heat at 30°F?
No. Approximately 30°F was the changeover approach described for this project. Settings should be selected for the specific equipment, home, and operating costs.